The Second Amendment defines our right to keep and bear arms: “A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.” It’s a pretty easy phrase to understand – and nowhere does it say “the right disappears if you’re demonstrating against the state.” Still, I wouldn’t go to a demonstration heeled. The fact that I have the right to do something stupid doesn’t mean I should do something stupid.
I recall a speeding stop a few years back – I had missed seeing the 35 mph sign, and the deputy wanted my proof of insurance and license documents – something that he had the authority to request. I leaned toward the jockey box and remembered I had a 38 laying on top of those documents. I explained that, and offered to step away from the car while he rummaged through my documents, receipts and revolver. His compromise was to take my word for their existence and write the ticket for the data I gave him. No problem – I had the right to have the 38, but it would have been bloody stupid not to offer a solution.
I tend to vote Second amendment – if a politician doesn’t trust me armed, I don’t trust him/her/it making laws that govern my life. All to often, we can agree on the Second and still have serious reasons to disagree. But along with the Right to Bear Arms comes the Responsibility Not To Do Something Stupid.
Places where police are making a bust are places best left without my presence. The cops generally don’t need me, and most of the time I don’t need them. You might say we have an identical, mutual expectation.
The FBI Director has stated that you don’t have a right to carry a gun to a demonstration. So far as the text goes, I thin he’s wrong. I also think he would agree with my conclusion that there is a responsibility not to do something stupid. I’m not going to be surprised if the investigations of the Minneapolis shooting come up with stupid contributions to the incidents from both demonstrators and police. Nothing says demonstrators are selected for high IQ – and there is court precedent that says it’s OK to discriminate against higher IQ candidates when hiring police. Plus the fact that being intelligent doesn’t keep you from doing something really, really stupid.
I have freedom of speech – and I have found times when keeping my mouth shut was a sensible decision. Likewise, there are times when not wearing a 1911 makes sense. Statistically, based on past incidences, I’m a lot more likely to run across a griz in my backyard than the average Minnesotan is. Still, the 1911 is heavy, gets in my way when I’m sitting in a car – though its dark colors and reddish grips do turn it into a heck of a fashion accessory.
I have the right to free speech. I have the right to peacefully assemble. I have the right to bear arms. I also have the responsibility to not do something stupid.
