Our country has many areas of socialism – the recent problems with air travel boiled down to the failures at FAA – and that abbreviation stands for Federal Aviation Administration. In the US, those folks are responsible for air traffic control. North of the border, air traffic control is handled by Nav Canada – a private operation that bought Canada’s government program thirty years ago. Flights in Canada didn’t shut down – and we have an example of a spot where private enterprise does a better job than the federal system.

Here in northwest Montana, one of our socialized systems is waste management. In my county, that is ran by the health department. In other words, Lincoln County’s garbage management is an exercise in socialism. The problem is that the department doesn’t consist of the best and brightest – it hires midwits, then promotes and keeps them. The poorest leave, and so do the best. They rallied for covid – but the Swedish socialists did a better job handling that problem than the American socialists did here.

The fact is that all of us live under mixed economic systems – whether we’re in the free enterprise US or the People’s Republic over in China. It’s just a question of how mixed the economy is – basically, under Capitalism, the rich become powerful (think Donald Trump). Under Socialism, the powerful become rich (think Nancy Pelosi). In both the US and the People’s Republic, I can find individuals who fit that simple explanation. At the state level, let’s not forget that Judy Martz, Montana’s Governor from 2001 to 2005, came into the governor’s mansion in Helena after a career of handling Butte’s garbage. I’m not sure how she fits those statements – but her career is a statement about the importance of garbage.

I look at healthcare – when I went through cancer, I was covered by DakotaCare -and, while the company is damned well affected by government policy, it doesn’t have the delays that Canada’s socialized medicine provides. I was awakened in the middle of a colonoscopy on Friday, shown the tumor, agreed that we should do something about it, and in surgery getting the tumor removed on Saturday. Canada’s surgeons are no less skilled – but their system doesn’t respond that quickly. It’s been over 17 years since our mixed system brought me next-day surgery, and a lot of people with longer delays in treatment have moved to the other side of the grass since 2009.

I suspect the problem with socialism is that it doesn’t recruit or keep the best and brightest. Fauci was good – but he was better at bureaucratic politics than medicine. I retired as South Dakota’s State Demographer – and demography is predominately a profession either in academia or government service. I like to think that I was better as an academic providing service to the state and the people. But the structure of my work was closer to socialism than free enterprise. Face it – people need plumbers. It isn’t difficult to get by without the services of a sociologist. Think back to Fauci – people need medical doctors. The thing was, he went from getting the MD to working in the politics of federal bureaucracy. Socialism can succeed if the program gets the right people – every time. Nobody manages to hire the right people every time.

So this morning, I’m reading about the Chiquita Canyon landfill (in Los Angeles) exploding. And I’m fairly certain that the official responsible for the methane explosion will turn out to be a midwit working for LA’s health department. And that reminds me of the Palisades fire, and the empty reservoir. Fighting fire is another socialized activity. Did it as a volunteer, did it while working for Smokey the Bear. Powering a Pulaski is usually a government job – Socialism.

The military became socialized – dig out the history books and you will read of the mercenary armies of the 17th century. Dozens, probably hundreds, of Americans owned their own warships during the Revolution – and the practice continued through the war between the states, with both Washington and Richmond issuing letters of Marque. Privately owned ships sailed along with the US Navy – basically the free enterprise fleets of the Revolution and the War of 1812 have been replaced by a socialized fleet. And most of our Military retirees vote to the right.

Thinking about it, we had a mixed capitalist and socialist economy before Karl Marx even thought of writing Das Kapital.

This is a family friendly website. Our spam filters automatically trash anything with inappropriate language. If you find your comments never show up, please review your username/email for anything that might be being caught in our spam filter.

Leave a Reply

Trending